You are here
Home ›Falklands Balance Sheet
What we said at the time... - From Workers’ Voice 8 (second series) August 1982
The re-taking of the Falkland Islands was a major military and propaganda victory for the British ruling class. The victory was also achieved without damage to the interests of US imperialism, which at first seemed threatened by the conflict with Argentina. The latter remains a member of the US bloc, chastened for its attempt to break the rules of bloc behaviour and as militarily and economically bound to the US as ever. Despite some wild talk by Galtieri and the Junta, there was never a prospect of Argentina moving towards Russia. The Russians themselves were so clear on this that they used the conflict to try and force down to their advantage Argentina’s asking price for its grain, rather than trying to make practical capital out of their verbal support for Argentina’s “rights”.
Militarily the whole operation was a success for Britain, and in the first naval battle since World War II many lessons were learned which will be of great use when the “real thing” comes. For example, the vulnerability of ships to missiles like the Exocet was dramatically revealed. The need for a massive combat fleet was shown and in future arms spending will undoubtedly be directed by all the NATO allies towards this away from the single-minded concentration on massively costly projects like Trident.
In propaganda terms, also, the ruling class achieved some success. There is little doubt that, after initial hesitations, the policy of Thatcher and co was seen by the mass of the population, including the working class, not as a transparent move to deflect attention from the economic crisis, but as a legitimate defence of democracy against fascist aggression.
Although some workers refused to call off their struggles (e.g. Hawker-Siddley workers in Bristol), these were minor problems for the ruling class. And although the Falklands mood of national unity began to evaporate once the war was over and reality began to intrude (e.g. rail and health strikes), the ease with which the ruling class mobilized for and carried out the war was a significant, though not final, setback for the working class, and a step towards World War III.
The war posed great problems and responsibilities for communists. The biggest political crisis in the UK for 25 years, it proved the validity of everything the CWO has said about the course of capitalism towards war as a solution to its crisis, and the role which the various parties and trades unions would play If it was a dress rehearsal for the ruling class it was also one for the CWO, which responded to the war by our most sustained campaign of action against the capitalist war via our press, leafleting, fly-posting and public meetings. The slogan was for class action against the capitalist war. The CWO took a consistently revolutionary defeatist position on the war, calling for opposition to both regimes in Britain and Argentina, and for working class unity and action against the war.
Social chauvinists to the fore
Communists haven’t always opposed all wars conducted by capitalism. Our attitude has been defined by the world interests of the working class in particular historical situations.
Marx and the First International supported the Northern capitalists in the American Civil War, because they were progressive - that is, their victory would lead to the abolition of slavery in the Southern states. But after the formation of the major capitalist states in the nineteenth century, as capitalism began to develop towards imperialism and to show that it was no longer a progressive social system, communists began to evolve a position of “revolutionary defeatism” in opposition to all sides in any capitalist war.
It was the Bolsheviks who first put forward the position of “revolutionary defeatism” in opposition to the prevailing mood of patriotism among the European socialist parties in the First World War. This means that socialists under no circumstances defend their own country, but work for its defeat by encouraging strikes and revolution against the ruling class, paralysing its ability to make war.
It was left to the left wing of the Communist International to continue this revolutionary tradition. The total opposition of the Italian fraction of the left led to its unique opposition to Stalin’s policy of forming a Popular Front with the bourgeoisie in Spain. In the Spanish Civil War, defence of democracy was the prelude to the anti-fascist crusade of WorId War II, in which the “communist” parties helped to mobilise the workers behind US, French and British Imperialism on the pretext of fighting fascism. Again, the remnants of the Italian Left took a revolutionary defeatist position and with the formation of the Internationalist Communist Party in 1943 the tradition of opposition to both imperialisms and internationalist revolutionary defeatism was carried on.
Today we can see clearly the signs of the build-up to World War III, just as the Spanish CiviI War was part of the preparation for the last imperialist massacre. We must prepare by opposing all the war preparations of the bourgeoisie of every country, whether under the banner of fighting fascism or anti-colonialism. Tomorrow, chauvinism of the right and left will be used to mobilise workers for World War III.
In World War I Lenin denounced those socia1 democrats who supported the war and who told the working class to fight for the aims of the bosses. He called them social chauvinists: socialists in words, chauvinist in deeds. When the war between Britain and Argentina broke out over the Falklands all sections of the left in Argentina played a chauvinist role, showing that they were simply left varieties of Argentine capitalism. A statement from the main Trotskyist group in Argentina stated:
The war, if there is one will mean more hunger for the workers and the people. However, this will not deter the Argentine workers and ourselves ... Without giving the slightest political support to the government, we will form part of the military camp of the dictatorship in the fight against the British Imperia1ists.
Published in Socialist Organiser, 6th May 1982
But Galtieri’s gamble was not an attack primarily on British imperialism, but against the working class of Argentina, which in the spring had begun to organise strikes and demonstrations against the Junta. To support the military camp of the dictatorship can only mean proclaiming “social peace” for the duration of the war - in other words, supporting the interests of the ruling class. This was exactly what the Argentine CGT (equivalent of the TUC) did when they called off all strikes and proclaimed their support for a regime which was soaked in workers’ blood. These chauvinists were not alone: the Argentine Communist Party supported the Junta, touring Europe to organise support, while the Monteneros guerrilla group volunteered to come back from Cuban exile and fight for the Junta that had all but exterminated them!
The British left was not to be outdone in chauvinism by the Argentine left, though some of them disguised their chauvinism with “internationalist” rhetoric - by supporting Argentina! The British trades unions loyally supported the war effort, as did the Argentine CGT. COHSE called off their industrial action in the hospitals for a week as a “mark of respect” for the dead. The T&GWU called off a national dock strike due to begin on 10th May to aid the war effort. The NUS encouraged seamen to volunteer for active war service, and jingoistically called for the Tories to “finish the job” quickly. Other union leaders went on record by denouncing the stupidity of the Tories - since they had not armed Britain well enough and cut too many jobs in the arms industry! The pacifism of the Labour Party also quickly evaporated, and it supported the British war effort, as it had done in World Wars I and II, and in subsequent occasions.
Foot and Co’s criticisms of the Tories were that they had not acted quickly enough or built enough warships to nip the Argentine fascist aggression in the bud. The Labour lefts’ opposition to the war was nothing but spurious pacifist phrase-mongering illusions that “negotiations” in the UN can remove capitalism’s drive to war. And Benn himself made clear his defence of capitalist society when be said,
... the nation will respond to a call to arms to defend a foreign invasion, or repel those who have successfully occupied a part of our country.
The Times, 29th April 1982
This was echoed by the pacifists of CND who had recently called out 250 000 people to demonstrate against Trident. They were conspicuous by their absence on the tiny demonstrations against the Falklands adventure. Their pamphlet Beyond the Cold War in fact echoes current Pentagon/Kremlin thinking in favour of conventional weapons against nuclear ones. “We are the real patriots” says Bruce Kent and their lack of opposition to the Falklands war lines up CND with the social patriots of the Labour Party and Trades Unions.
Most of the far left in Britain, particularly the various Trotskyist groups, noisily announced their support of Galtieri - the WRP, RCP and others all took this line. Workers’ Power, for example, in their statement of 4th April 1982 revealed their anti-working class chauvinism clearly,
In a conflict over the islands we are for the victory of the Argentines despite their political regime... and despite the fact that this clash... is undertaken for demagogic reasons, i.e. to head off mass revolt against the dictatorship.
In other words, they are for the crushing of the Argentine working class. Some groups like the SWF, after an initial flirtation with support for Argentina, moved towards a pacifist position, i.e. of being opposed to both sides, but without calling for any working class action against the war, and while chiding the CND and Labour left for their inactivity and failure to “give a lead”.
The total inability of these groups to adopt an internationalist perspective on such a stupid little war, confirms that when a real war comes along, they will be at best useless and irrelevant, and at worst active supporters of one or other group of capitalist hangmen.
Revolutionary Perspectives
Journal of the Communist Workers’ Organisation -- Why not subscribe to get the articles whilst they are still current and help the struggle for a society free from exploitation, war and misery? Joint subscriptions to Revolutionary Perspectives (3 issues) and Aurora (our agitational bulletin - 4 issues) are £15 in the UK, €24 in Europe and $30 in the rest of the World.
Revolutionary Perspectives #41
Winter/Spring 2007 (Series 3)
Start here...
- Navigating the Basics
- Platform
- For Communism
- Introduction to Our History
- CWO Social Media
- IWG Social Media
- Klasbatalo Social Media
- Italian Communist Left
- Russian Communist Left
The Internationalist Communist Tendency consists of (unsurprisingly!) not-for-profit organisations. We have no so-called “professional revolutionaries”, nor paid officials. Our sole funding comes from the subscriptions and donations of members and supporters. Anyone wishing to donate can now do so safely using the Paypal buttons below.
ICT publications are not copyrighted and we only ask that those who reproduce them acknowledge the original source (author and website leftcom.org). Purchasing any of the publications listed (see catalogue) can be done in two ways:
- By emailing us at uk@leftcom.org, us@leftcom.org or ca@leftcom.org and asking for our banking details
- By donating the cost of the publications required via Paypal using the “Donate” buttons
The CWO also offers subscriptions to Revolutionary Perspectives (3 issues) and Aurora (at least 4 issues):
- UK £15 (€18)
- Europe £20 (€24)
- World £25 (€30, $30)
Take out a supporter’s sub by adding £10 (€12) to each sum. This will give you priority mailings of Aurora and other free pamphlets as they are produced.
ICT sections
Basics
- Bourgeois revolution
- Competition and monopoly
- Core and peripheral countries
- Crisis
- Decadence
- Democracy and dictatorship
- Exploitation and accumulation
- Factory and territory groups
- Financialization
- Globalization
- Historical materialism
- Imperialism
- Our Intervention
- Party and class
- Proletarian revolution
- Seigniorage
- Social classes
- Socialism and communism
- State
- State capitalism
- War economics
Facts
- Activities
- Arms
- Automotive industry
- Books, art and culture
- Commerce
- Communications
- Conflicts
- Contracts and wages
- Corporate trends
- Criminal activities
- Disasters
- Discriminations
- Discussions
- Drugs and dependencies
- Economic policies
- Education and youth
- Elections and polls
- Energy, oil and fuels
- Environment and resources
- Financial market
- Food
- Health and social assistance
- Housing
- Information and media
- International relations
- Law
- Migrations
- Pensions and benefits
- Philosophy and religion
- Repression and control
- Science and technics
- Social unrest
- Terrorist outrages
- Transports
- Unemployment and precarity
- Workers' conditions and struggles
History
- 01. Prehistory
- 02. Ancient History
- 03. Middle Ages
- 04. Modern History
- 1800: Industrial Revolution
- 1900s
- 1910s
- 1911-12: Turko-Italian War for Libya
- 1912: Intransigent Revolutionary Fraction of the PSI
- 1912: Republic of China
- 1913: Fordism (assembly line)
- 1914-18: World War I
- 1917: Russian Revolution
- 1918: Abstentionist Communist Fraction of the PSI
- 1918: German Revolution
- 1919-20: Biennio Rosso in Italy
- 1919-43: Third International
- 1919: Hungarian Revolution
- 1930s
- 1931: Japan occupies Manchuria
- 1933-43: New Deal
- 1933-45: Nazism
- 1934: Long March of Chinese communists
- 1934: Miners' uprising in Asturias
- 1934: Workers' uprising in "Red Vienna"
- 1935-36: Italian Army Invades Ethiopia
- 1936-38: Great Purge
- 1936-39: Spanish Civil War
- 1937: International Bureau of Fractions of the Communist Left
- 1938: Fourth International
- 1940s
- 1960s
- 1980s
- 1979-89: Soviet war in Afghanistan
- 1980-88: Iran-Iraq War
- 1982: First Lebanon War
- 1982: Sabra and Chatila
- 1986: Chernobyl disaster
- 1987-93: First Intifada
- 1989: Fall of the Berlin Wall
- 1979-90: Thatcher Government
- 1980: Strikes in Poland
- 1982: Falklands War
- 1983: Foundation of IBRP
- 1984-85: UK Miners' Strike
- 1987: Perestroika
- 1989: Tiananmen Square Protests
- 1990s
- 1991: Breakup of Yugoslavia
- 1991: Dissolution of Soviet Union
- 1991: First Gulf War
- 1992-95: UN intervention in Somalia
- 1994-96: First Chechen War
- 1994: Genocide in Rwanda
- 1999-2000: Second Chechen War
- 1999: Introduction of euro
- 1999: Kosovo War
- 1999: WTO conference in Seattle
- 1995: NATO Bombing in Bosnia
- 2000s
- 2000: Second intifada
- 2001: September 11 attacks
- 2001: Piqueteros Movement in Argentina
- 2001: War in Afghanistan
- 2001: G8 Summit in Genoa
- 2003: Second Gulf War
- 2004: Asian Tsunami
- 2004: Madrid train bombings
- 2005: Banlieue riots in France
- 2005: Hurricane Katrina
- 2005: London bombings
- 2006: Anti-CPE movement in France
- 2006: Comuna de Oaxaca
- 2006: Second Lebanon War
- 2007: Subprime Crisis
- 2008: Onda movement in Italy
- 2008: War in Georgia
- 2008: Riots in Greece
- 2008: Pomigliano Struggle
- 2008: Global Crisis
- 2008: Automotive Crisis
- 2009: Post-election crisis in Iran
- 2009: Israel-Gaza conflict
- 2020s
- 1920s
- 1921-28: New Economic Policy
- 1921: Communist Party of Italy
- 1921: Kronstadt Rebellion
- 1922-45: Fascism
- 1922-52: Stalin is General Secretary of PCUS
- 1925-27: Canton and Shanghai revolt
- 1925: Comitato d'Intesa
- 1926: General strike in Britain
- 1926: Lyons Congress of PCd’I
- 1927: Vienna revolt
- 1928: First five-year plan
- 1928: Left Fraction of the PCd'I
- 1929: Great Depression
- 1950s
- 1970s
- 1969-80: Anni di piombo in Italy
- 1971: End of the Bretton Woods System
- 1971: Microprocessor
- 1973: Pinochet's military junta in Chile
- 1975: Toyotism (just-in-time)
- 1977-81: International Conferences Convoked by PCInt
- 1977: '77 movement
- 1978: Economic Reforms in China
- 1978: Islamic Revolution in Iran
- 1978: South Lebanon conflict
- 2010s
- 2010: Greek debt crisis
- 2011: War in Libya
- 2011: Indignados and Occupy movements
- 2011: Sovereign debt crisis
- 2011: Tsunami and Nuclear Disaster in Japan
- 2011: Uprising in Maghreb
- 2014: Euromaidan
- 2016: Brexit Referendum
- 2017: Catalan Referendum
- 2019: Maquiladoras Struggle
- 2010: Student Protests in UK and Italy
- 2011: War in Syria
- 2013: Black Lives Matter Movement
- 2014: Military Intervention Against ISIS
- 2015: Refugee Crisis
- 2018: Haft Tappeh Struggle
- 2018: Climate Movement
People
- Amadeo Bordiga
- Anton Pannekoek
- Antonio Gramsci
- Arrigo Cervetto
- Bruno Fortichiari
- Bruno Maffi
- Celso Beltrami
- Davide Casartelli
- Errico Malatesta
- Fabio Damen
- Fausto Atti
- Franco Migliaccio
- Franz Mehring
- Friedrich Engels
- Giorgio Paolucci
- Guido Torricelli
- Heinz Langerhans
- Helmut Wagner
- Henryk Grossmann
- Karl Korsch
- Karl Liebknecht
- Karl Marx
- Leon Trotsky
- Lorenzo Procopio
- Mario Acquaviva
- Mauro jr. Stefanini
- Michail Bakunin
- Onorato Damen
- Ottorino Perrone (Vercesi)
- Paul Mattick
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Vladimir Lenin
Politics
- Anarchism
- Anti-Americanism
- Anti-Globalization Movement
- Antifascism and United Front
- Antiracism
- Armed Struggle
- Autonomism and Workerism
- Base Unionism
- Bordigism
- Communist Left Inspired
- Cooperativism and autogestion
- DeLeonism
- Environmentalism
- Fascism
- Feminism
- German-Dutch Communist Left
- Gramscism
- ICC and French Communist Left
- Islamism
- Italian Communist Left
- Leninism
- Liberism
- Luxemburgism
- Maoism
- Marxism
- National Liberation Movements
- Nationalism
- No War But The Class War
- PCInt-ICT
- Pacifism
- Parliamentary Center-Right
- Parliamentary Left and Reformism
- Peasant movement
- Revolutionary Unionism
- Russian Communist Left
- Situationism
- Stalinism
- Statism and Keynesism
- Student Movement
- Titoism
- Trotskyism
- Unionism
Regions
User login
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.