You are here
Home ›The Death of Sheila Seleoane: Another Capitalist Housing Scandal
The tragic death of Sheila Seleoane tells us a lot about modern capitalism. Sheila was a medical secretary who lived alone in a housing association flat. She was an agency worker, so when she died, sometime in 2019, she wasn’t missed at work. In fact the only people who realised something was wrong were her neighbours. One of them recalls being alarmed by the ‘strong smell of death.’ When they contacted their landlord, the Peabody Trust, they were ignored. When maggots started coming through the light fittings of the flat below, they were ignored again. When Peabody realised Sheila hadn’t paid her rent, instead of checking on her, they applied for housing benefit on her behalf. And when, almost a year after Sheila had last been seen, gas engineers couldn’t get access to do a safety check, they cut off her gas supply. Sheila’s body lay undetected for two and a half years. Her neighbours, ignored at every turn, remain traumatised.
The Roots of Today’s Housing Crisis
Michael Gove, the ‘Levelling up’ Tsar, immediately criticised the Cameron coalition government’s cuts (neatly sidestepping the fact he was part of that government in 2010). He also took aim at Peabody’s target-driven values as part of a ‘wider culture of neglect.’ He’s partly right, but in fact Sheila’s landlord, Peabody, was set up in 1862 by George Peabody, an American philanthropist, to provide decent housing for London’s workers. Peabody has prided itself since on its social conscience. So, what went wrong?
Sheila’s landlord initially was a small London housing association. Her neighbours describe how they knew their housing officer and who to contact in an emergency. But since 2010, that model of small-scale local housing associations has changed. To pay for propping up the banking system after the meltdown of 2008, the coalition government introduced swingeing cuts in funding, slashing the budget for affordable housing by 60%. Funding for new builds in social housing was stopped altogether. So Housing Associations had to figure a way to generate income to build new homes. They did it by cross subsidy, by building homes for sale on the private market, then using the proceeds to build new homes for the social sector. Over four years they’d managed to build 20,000 social rented homes with this method. But they had, ironically, to borrow from banks. And that meant they had to shift from being just a landlord to being a viable, competitive business. The bigger they could become, the better chance of loans from the banks. Peabody isn’t alone in turning into a mega corporation. The larger housing associations have been swallowing up the smaller, locally based ones for over a decade now. And to deal with all the properties they manage, they’ve developed centralised systems with call centres. In the past a housing officer might have a patch of 200 properties that they’d walk around, dealing with whatever problems arose. Now housing managers are dealing with 1,000 people a time. Which is why, when Sheila’s neighbours rang to raise the alarm that something was very wrong, they were told: ‘we don’t deal with smells’.
Tragedies like Sheila’s, let alone horrendous disasters like Grenfell(1), don’t come out of nowhere. They happen because of decades of attacks on the social wage and workers’ living standards. Social housing especially has been deliberately destroyed by successive governments over the past 40 years. The Right to Buy (RTB) was Thatcher’s big dream of making everyone middle class home owners. The notion that the right to buy would create a property-owning democracy now looks laughable to a nation of renters paying through their teeth for sub-standard, insecure accommodation. Because RTB rules meant that councils couldn’t keep the sales money to build new stock, less than 5% of the homes sold off have been replaced. The total number of council homes fell from 5.2 million in 1979 to 1.6 million in 2021. And over the decades those homes have fallen into the hands of private landlords. Nationally the figure is 40.2% but in some parts of the country it’s well over half. Far from creating a nation of home owners, RTB has created a new set of extremely wealthy private landlords. The council stock that’s left is bitterly fought for by growing numbers on the housing list, but it’s also the worst of the stock that’s left after everything else has been snapped up. Councils are struggling with unpopular stock that’s increasingly run down and underfunded after decades of cuts.
Rents have rocketed, and with it the housing benefit bill, which, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, stands at a staggering £22 billion a year, doubled since the 90’s. It's now more than spending on the police, on overseas aid, and it dwarfs the spending of a lot of government departments. So we’re now in a situation where eye-watering amounts of money are going to private landlords who have inflated their rents while providing increasingly sub-standard, barely regulated accommodation. The government’s answer? In 2012 it blamed lazy workshy tenants and introduced a benefits cap, reducing the total amount of benefits a family can claim in a year, and reducing the amount of housing benefit that could be claimed by an individual. So housing benefit no longer covered the cost of the rent. Tenants have to make up the shortfall, and in high rent areas like London that can be up to a quarter of the bill. The notion of ‘encouraging’ people into work of course assumes those who claim benefits don’t work. In fact most workers in low-waged, zero-hours jobs have to claim benefits to make up the wages shortfall. And with inflated rents that leaves them stuck in the benefits system and in a very vicious cycle.
Housing: a human need or capitalist commodity?
Food, clothing and shelter are the fundamental needs of humanity in every epoch. Under capitalism, housing has become a commodity like everything else. Property speculation (which thrives when profits are hard to come by other means) has made it financially impossible for many. The social, health and emotional costs to millions of people desperate for decent housing are the consequences. According to the National Housing Federation, 4.2 million people in England alone are in need of social housing, including 1.3 million children. Some can wait on the list for decades. And if they are lucky enough to get to the top of the list, the accommodation they’re offered is often sub-standard, or worse, dangerous.
In 2020, two year old Awaab Ishak died eight days after his second birthday following ‘chronic exposure’ to black mould in the flat he lived in. Rochdale Boroughwide Housing, which owned the flat, ignored his parents’ concerns about the mould over a number of years, telling them at one stage to paint over it. His parents described pleading for help for their son right until the day he died. The coroner said Awaab’s death should be a “defining moment” for the UK’s housing sector. It should be, but it won’t, just as Grenfell wasn’t. The death of a child due to substandard housing is as shocking as it is unforgivable. It speaks volumes about the way the poorest and most vulnerable workers and their kids are treated, but this is the reality of much of the housing stock in Britain; run-down, cut to the bone and unfit for purpose.
Of course poor housing isn’t just confined to the social sector. According to Shelter, 1 in 5 renters over both sectors in 2021 said the state of their home was harming their health. Over a quarter were suffering with damp and mould. Since private landlords are far less regulated than councils or housing associations, this figure could be a lot higher.
Over the decades, decent, affordable housing has been promised by successive governments and delivered by none. Housing policies have either been totally ineffectual or have made the problem worse. There isn’t a simple ‘get the Tories out’ solution to this. It’s a systemic problem and goes right to the heart of capitalism itself.
Philanthropists like Peabody in the nineteenth century were so appalled by the slums they tried to fix it. But individual capitalists couldn’t solve the housing problem. Nor can the state. Capitalism has always had a housing crisis. It couldn’t solve it in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries and it’s even less equipped to do it now. It won’t ever meet the fundamental, basic human need of providing a decent home for everyone who needs one, because that won’t turn a profit. Every single one of us is entitled to live somewhere safe that fits our needs. But only a global, classless system producing for human need will be able to provide that for everyone.
RTCommunist Workers’ Organisation
Notes:
Image: Luc Legay, (CC BY-SA 2.0), flickr.com
(1) For our analysis of this see leftcom.org
Some other articles on the housing question from leftcom.org:
For a Class Analysis of the Housing Question
Homes to Those Who Live in Them!
The Housing Question: An Eternal Riddle for Capitalism
Housing Crisis UK – the Death of the “Property-owning Democracy”
Under Capitalism the Housing Problem Never Goes Away
The Bosses' Response to Being Socially Useless is Social Crisis
Start here...
- Navigating the Basics
- Platform
- For Communism
- Introduction to Our History
- CWO Social Media
- IWG Social Media
- Klasbatalo Social Media
- Italian Communist Left
- Russian Communist Left
The Internationalist Communist Tendency consists of (unsurprisingly!) not-for-profit organisations. We have no so-called “professional revolutionaries”, nor paid officials. Our sole funding comes from the subscriptions and donations of members and supporters. Anyone wishing to donate can now do so safely using the Paypal buttons below.
ICT publications are not copyrighted and we only ask that those who reproduce them acknowledge the original source (author and website leftcom.org). Purchasing any of the publications listed (see catalogue) can be done in two ways:
- By emailing us at uk@leftcom.org, us@leftcom.org or ca@leftcom.org and asking for our banking details
- By donating the cost of the publications required via Paypal using the “Donate” buttons
The CWO also offers subscriptions to Revolutionary Perspectives (3 issues) and Aurora (at least 4 issues):
- UK £15 (€18)
- Europe £20 (€24)
- World £25 (€30, $30)
Take out a supporter’s sub by adding £10 (€12) to each sum. This will give you priority mailings of Aurora and other free pamphlets as they are produced.
ICT sections
Basics
- Bourgeois revolution
- Competition and monopoly
- Core and peripheral countries
- Crisis
- Decadence
- Democracy and dictatorship
- Exploitation and accumulation
- Factory and territory groups
- Financialization
- Globalization
- Historical materialism
- Imperialism
- Our Intervention
- Party and class
- Proletarian revolution
- Seigniorage
- Social classes
- Socialism and communism
- State
- State capitalism
- War economics
Facts
- Activities
- Arms
- Automotive industry
- Books, art and culture
- Commerce
- Communications
- Conflicts
- Contracts and wages
- Corporate trends
- Criminal activities
- Disasters
- Discriminations
- Discussions
- Drugs and dependencies
- Economic policies
- Education and youth
- Elections and polls
- Energy, oil and fuels
- Environment and resources
- Financial market
- Food
- Health and social assistance
- Housing
- Information and media
- International relations
- Law
- Migrations
- Pensions and benefits
- Philosophy and religion
- Repression and control
- Science and technics
- Social unrest
- Terrorist outrages
- Transports
- Unemployment and precarity
- Workers' conditions and struggles
History
- 01. Prehistory
- 02. Ancient History
- 03. Middle Ages
- 04. Modern History
- 1800: Industrial Revolution
- 1900s
- 1910s
- 1911-12: Turko-Italian War for Libya
- 1912: Intransigent Revolutionary Fraction of the PSI
- 1912: Republic of China
- 1913: Fordism (assembly line)
- 1914-18: World War I
- 1917: Russian Revolution
- 1918: Abstentionist Communist Fraction of the PSI
- 1918: German Revolution
- 1919-20: Biennio Rosso in Italy
- 1919-43: Third International
- 1919: Hungarian Revolution
- 1930s
- 1931: Japan occupies Manchuria
- 1933-43: New Deal
- 1933-45: Nazism
- 1934: Long March of Chinese communists
- 1934: Miners' uprising in Asturias
- 1934: Workers' uprising in "Red Vienna"
- 1935-36: Italian Army Invades Ethiopia
- 1936-38: Great Purge
- 1936-39: Spanish Civil War
- 1937: International Bureau of Fractions of the Communist Left
- 1938: Fourth International
- 1940s
- 1960s
- 1980s
- 1979-89: Soviet war in Afghanistan
- 1980-88: Iran-Iraq War
- 1982: First Lebanon War
- 1982: Sabra and Chatila
- 1986: Chernobyl disaster
- 1987-93: First Intifada
- 1989: Fall of the Berlin Wall
- 1979-90: Thatcher Government
- 1980: Strikes in Poland
- 1982: Falklands War
- 1983: Foundation of IBRP
- 1984-85: UK Miners' Strike
- 1987: Perestroika
- 1989: Tiananmen Square Protests
- 1990s
- 1991: Breakup of Yugoslavia
- 1991: Dissolution of Soviet Union
- 1991: First Gulf War
- 1992-95: UN intervention in Somalia
- 1994-96: First Chechen War
- 1994: Genocide in Rwanda
- 1999-2000: Second Chechen War
- 1999: Introduction of euro
- 1999: Kosovo War
- 1999: WTO conference in Seattle
- 1995: NATO Bombing in Bosnia
- 2000s
- 2000: Second intifada
- 2001: September 11 attacks
- 2001: Piqueteros Movement in Argentina
- 2001: War in Afghanistan
- 2001: G8 Summit in Genoa
- 2003: Second Gulf War
- 2004: Asian Tsunami
- 2004: Madrid train bombings
- 2005: Banlieue riots in France
- 2005: Hurricane Katrina
- 2005: London bombings
- 2006: Anti-CPE movement in France
- 2006: Comuna de Oaxaca
- 2006: Second Lebanon War
- 2007: Subprime Crisis
- 2008: Onda movement in Italy
- 2008: War in Georgia
- 2008: Riots in Greece
- 2008: Pomigliano Struggle
- 2008: Global Crisis
- 2008: Automotive Crisis
- 2009: Post-election crisis in Iran
- 2009: Israel-Gaza conflict
- 2020s
- 1920s
- 1921-28: New Economic Policy
- 1921: Communist Party of Italy
- 1921: Kronstadt Rebellion
- 1922-45: Fascism
- 1922-52: Stalin is General Secretary of PCUS
- 1925-27: Canton and Shanghai revolt
- 1925: Comitato d'Intesa
- 1926: General strike in Britain
- 1926: Lyons Congress of PCd’I
- 1927: Vienna revolt
- 1928: First five-year plan
- 1928: Left Fraction of the PCd'I
- 1929: Great Depression
- 1950s
- 1970s
- 1969-80: Anni di piombo in Italy
- 1971: End of the Bretton Woods System
- 1971: Microprocessor
- 1973: Pinochet's military junta in Chile
- 1975: Toyotism (just-in-time)
- 1977-81: International Conferences Convoked by PCInt
- 1977: '77 movement
- 1978: Economic Reforms in China
- 1978: Islamic Revolution in Iran
- 1978: South Lebanon conflict
- 2010s
- 2010: Greek debt crisis
- 2011: War in Libya
- 2011: Indignados and Occupy movements
- 2011: Sovereign debt crisis
- 2011: Tsunami and Nuclear Disaster in Japan
- 2011: Uprising in Maghreb
- 2014: Euromaidan
- 2016: Brexit Referendum
- 2017: Catalan Referendum
- 2019: Maquiladoras Struggle
- 2010: Student Protests in UK and Italy
- 2011: War in Syria
- 2013: Black Lives Matter Movement
- 2014: Military Intervention Against ISIS
- 2015: Refugee Crisis
- 2018: Haft Tappeh Struggle
- 2018: Climate Movement
People
- Amadeo Bordiga
- Anton Pannekoek
- Antonio Gramsci
- Arrigo Cervetto
- Bruno Fortichiari
- Bruno Maffi
- Celso Beltrami
- Davide Casartelli
- Errico Malatesta
- Fabio Damen
- Fausto Atti
- Franco Migliaccio
- Franz Mehring
- Friedrich Engels
- Giorgio Paolucci
- Guido Torricelli
- Heinz Langerhans
- Helmut Wagner
- Henryk Grossmann
- Karl Korsch
- Karl Liebknecht
- Karl Marx
- Leon Trotsky
- Lorenzo Procopio
- Mario Acquaviva
- Mauro jr. Stefanini
- Michail Bakunin
- Onorato Damen
- Ottorino Perrone (Vercesi)
- Paul Mattick
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Vladimir Lenin
Politics
- Anarchism
- Anti-Americanism
- Anti-Globalization Movement
- Antifascism and United Front
- Antiracism
- Armed Struggle
- Autonomism and Workerism
- Base Unionism
- Bordigism
- Communist Left Inspired
- Cooperativism and autogestion
- DeLeonism
- Environmentalism
- Fascism
- Feminism
- German-Dutch Communist Left
- Gramscism
- ICC and French Communist Left
- Islamism
- Italian Communist Left
- Leninism
- Liberism
- Luxemburgism
- Maoism
- Marxism
- National Liberation Movements
- Nationalism
- No War But The Class War
- PCInt-ICT
- Pacifism
- Parliamentary Center-Right
- Parliamentary Left and Reformism
- Peasant movement
- Revolutionary Unionism
- Russian Communist Left
- Situationism
- Stalinism
- Statism and Keynesism
- Student Movement
- Titoism
- Trotskyism
- Unionism
Regions
User login
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.