You are here
Home ›Turkey: The Trade Unions Are An Obstacle To All Workers' Struggles
In our last article we mentioned the strikes that sprang up in many sectors.(1) Workers in the Alpin Socks factory, BBC Turkey and Trendyol have already gained from their strikes; other strikes are still ongoing. We also hear interesting examples of solidarity in the written and audiovisual interviews of workers. For example, when workers of the Migros grocery warehouse went on strike, the Migros company tried to break the strike by bringing in new workers from neighboring provinces, but the newly arrived workers also started to support the strikers. Worker organizations from many sectors are announcing one by one that they "went on strike with the courage they got from each other".
In such a situation, workers are sometimes attacked by the police. This was the case with the Migros warehouse workers, where more than 150 workers were detained, and 250 were sacked. In this respect, we think the clearest example is Farplas Automotive. Workers at the Farplas factory in Kocaeli-Gebze, where the United Metal Workers’ Union affiliated to DİSK (Confederation of Progressive Trade Unions of Turkey) is organized, went on strike for their union rights. As a result, 150 workers were sacked. Thereupon, the workers on the shift occupied the factory, locking themselves in demanding both their union rights and for their colleagues to be re-instated. As the police prepared for the attack, the workers climbed onto the roof of the factory and announced that they would jump down if they did not get what they wanted. As a result, 200 workers were taken into custody. While this picture shows the swamp into which capitalism has dragged the working class, it was also an indication that the "legal limits" in which the trade union tries to imprison the struggle were not enough to contain the working class. Which shows that in going beyond the “legal” limits of the union at critical moments, workers can create their own methods of struggle.
For example, during the strikes of Migros, Trendyol and Yemek Sepeti workers, there were calls for a boycott of these companies. A boycott has the advantage of giving the workers a tool to make quick gains, but on the other hand, it reduces strikes to a local and legal perspective. Moreover, the majority of people's support for the boycott is shaped by the fact that Migros does not give workers their "rights". Thus, the enemy is reduced to a few capitalist companies that do not grant rights, rather than seeing that the problem is capitalism itself. The trade union’s role as "mediator" between capital and the working class ultimately leads them to "compromise" and enables them to consider the struggle as "the struggle for the rights of the working class against the bourgeoisie". The “struggle for rights” keeps the struggle of the working class within the legal boundaries of the capitalist system, and the legitimacy of the struggle of the working class remains within the framework defined by bourgeois law. Politically, "rights" do not go beyond a few legal and material "gains" that the working class might achieve in the face of the economic and political crisis of the bourgeoisie. This is why the spokesperson of a so-called independent union can say, "we will stay away from unpleasant actions" in the struggles to come, even though the Trendyol workers won a 38.8% raise by fighting.
On the other hand, Nakliyat İş (Transport Workers Union), in which Yemeksepeti couriers are organized, saluted the struggle of the workers and said that the workers would win "under the leadership of Nakliyat İş". The bourgeois left and the trade unions show their Stalinist reflexes in the current actions in Turkey, by substituting themselves for the class and ignoring the real struggle of the workers. The gains achieved by the workers are not through the union methods, or via organizations and political parties of the capitalist and reformist left; they are achieved through the courage, solidarity and unity of the workers themselves. As communists, our duty is to strive to raise the consciousness of the working class to a revolutionary level, to spread the workers' struggles to the widest masses and to fight to establish the international party, which is the working class's own party, not to take the place of the class and leave their struggle in the shade, or to act as a leadership separated from the class.
Why The Worki̇ng Class Should Go Beyond The Uni̇on Struggle?
In this whole worker-union-capitalism triangle, it is not surprising that the workers' first resort to struggle is within the unions; the most accessible area of legal struggle are the unions. In this economic crisis where survival is difficult, the unions’ legal framework is seen as a useful choice for workers who are afraid of being laid off. However, the gains made by the workers through these struggles will not last long given the continuing crisis of capitalism. But, by recognizing the nature of capitalism and its ideological attacks, through tools of mediation (such as capitalist parties, unions, elections), and realizing that they have to carry their struggle to an international dimension, workers will make permanent gains in the struggle for a classless society. This is the reason why we use "criticism", which is the most important tool of Marxism in the struggle:
As Marx also said, in another context, “if things and their essence were the same then what need for science?”. In other words we have to explain what lies behind the phenomenon we are looking at. A slightly closer look at the union issue reveals an altogether different reality.(2)
Unions have always historically had the role of "mediator", but in the past this was not always clear for many reasons. Now, there are no obstacles behind which they can hide that their chief role as mediator is to make “compromises” but always in favor of the bosses. The reformists claim that the only problem with the unions is their leaders or that they are bureaucratic, and that therefore the unions are a field of struggle that must be seized by the "revolutionaries", but this has been repeatedly refuted by experience which shows that whoever heads the union behaves in the same way. Therefore, we can only understand the problem by looking at the role and function, not the specific features of unions.
The fact that unions are an agent of mediation between capital and labor is an element that should be evaluated historically. The unions that emerged in the 19th century were created by workers themselves. Until late in the 19th century they were illegal. However, as the contradictions of capitalism mounted, as we moved towards the epoch of imperialism, the state was drawn more and more into the process of trying to hold the system together. As part of this the role of the union as “mediator” to fix the rate of exploitation was gradually recognized as a positive for capitalism. The state not only recognized the unions but gave them legal status. Thus, the unions were also imprisoned within the framework of “legitimacy”. And they rewarded the capitalist states everywhere in World War One by suspending strikes and declaring their support for the war aims of each national capital. And the more the unions since then have pledged their loyalty to the system, as long as it gave the workers a few crumbs here and there, the more bureaucratic they have become, and the less they have represented the real interests of the workers. This critical understanding of what the unions have become should not be understood as an abstract call to "leave the unions". Although we reject any official position in unions (including at the lowest levels) as revolutionaries we are always where the workers are. We can only express the real interests of workers if we remain free of any involvement with the bureaucracy. We support the struggle of the working class in every area but insist this can only happen when the workers themselves create their own forms of struggle in assemblies and elected strike committees. We try to emphasize that the class has to gain its self-confidence and spread its struggle to large masses by overcoming the limited nature of the trade union struggle. The class struggle, which has risen again in the crisis, must avoid the left, which is stuck in the bourgeois ideology that imposes "rights" and reforms on itself. The working class must realize that only a revolutionary international struggle can create a classless society, and that the fate of the planet is in our hands. Capitalism’s mounting crises show that this struggle is more urgent than ever. We have a world to win!
Mimi and MedusaICT Sympathizers in Turkey
Notes:
Placards in the photo read: "has DİSK cheated us?", "unions go hand in hand with the municipality in causing workers' misery", etc.
Start here...
- Navigating the Basics
- Platform
- For Communism
- Introduction to Our History
- CWO Social Media
- IWG Social Media
- Klasbatalo Social Media
- Italian Communist Left
- Russian Communist Left
The Internationalist Communist Tendency consists of (unsurprisingly!) not-for-profit organisations. We have no so-called “professional revolutionaries”, nor paid officials. Our sole funding comes from the subscriptions and donations of members and supporters. Anyone wishing to donate can now do so safely using the Paypal buttons below.
ICT publications are not copyrighted and we only ask that those who reproduce them acknowledge the original source (author and website leftcom.org). Purchasing any of the publications listed (see catalogue) can be done in two ways:
- By emailing us at uk@leftcom.org, us@leftcom.org or ca@leftcom.org and asking for our banking details
- By donating the cost of the publications required via Paypal using the “Donate” buttons
- By cheque made out to "Prometheus Publications" and sending it to the following address: CWO, BM CWO, London, WC1N 3XX
The CWO also offers subscriptions to Revolutionary Perspectives (3 issues) and Aurora (at least 4 issues):
- UK £15 (€18)
- Europe £20 (€24)
- World £25 (€30, $30)
Take out a supporter’s sub by adding £10 (€12) to each sum. This will give you priority mailings of Aurora and other free pamphlets as they are produced.
ICT sections
Basics
- Bourgeois revolution
- Competition and monopoly
- Core and peripheral countries
- Crisis
- Decadence
- Democracy and dictatorship
- Exploitation and accumulation
- Factory and territory groups
- Financialization
- Globalization
- Historical materialism
- Imperialism
- Our Intervention
- Party and class
- Proletarian revolution
- Seigniorage
- Social classes
- Socialism and communism
- State
- State capitalism
- War economics
Facts
- Activities
- Arms
- Automotive industry
- Books, art and culture
- Commerce
- Communications
- Conflicts
- Contracts and wages
- Corporate trends
- Criminal activities
- Disasters
- Discriminations
- Discussions
- Drugs and dependencies
- Economic policies
- Education and youth
- Elections and polls
- Energy, oil and fuels
- Environment and resources
- Financial market
- Food
- Health and social assistance
- Housing
- Information and media
- International relations
- Law
- Migrations
- Pensions and benefits
- Philosophy and religion
- Repression and control
- Science and technics
- Social unrest
- Terrorist outrages
- Transports
- Unemployment and precarity
- Workers' conditions and struggles
History
- 01. Prehistory
- 02. Ancient History
- 03. Middle Ages
- 04. Modern History
- 1800: Industrial Revolution
- 1900s
- 1910s
- 1911-12: Turko-Italian War for Libya
- 1912: Intransigent Revolutionary Fraction of the PSI
- 1912: Republic of China
- 1913: Fordism (assembly line)
- 1914-18: World War I
- 1917: Russian Revolution
- 1918: Abstentionist Communist Fraction of the PSI
- 1918: German Revolution
- 1919-20: Biennio Rosso in Italy
- 1919-43: Third International
- 1919: Hungarian Revolution
- 1930s
- 1931: Japan occupies Manchuria
- 1933-43: New Deal
- 1933-45: Nazism
- 1934: Long March of Chinese communists
- 1934: Miners' uprising in Asturias
- 1934: Workers' uprising in "Red Vienna"
- 1935-36: Italian Army Invades Ethiopia
- 1936-38: Great Purge
- 1936-39: Spanish Civil War
- 1937: International Bureau of Fractions of the Communist Left
- 1938: Fourth International
- 1940s
- 1960s
- 1980s
- 1979-89: Soviet war in Afghanistan
- 1980-88: Iran-Iraq War
- 1982: First Lebanon War
- 1982: Sabra and Chatila
- 1986: Chernobyl disaster
- 1987-93: First Intifada
- 1989: Fall of the Berlin Wall
- 1979-90: Thatcher Government
- 1980: Strikes in Poland
- 1982: Falklands War
- 1983: Foundation of IBRP
- 1984-85: UK Miners' Strike
- 1987: Perestroika
- 1989: Tiananmen Square Protests
- 1990s
- 1991: Breakup of Yugoslavia
- 1991: Dissolution of Soviet Union
- 1991: First Gulf War
- 1992-95: UN intervention in Somalia
- 1994-96: First Chechen War
- 1994: Genocide in Rwanda
- 1999-2000: Second Chechen War
- 1999: Introduction of euro
- 1999: Kosovo War
- 1999: WTO conference in Seattle
- 1995: NATO Bombing in Bosnia
- 2000s
- 2000: Second intifada
- 2001: September 11 attacks
- 2001: Piqueteros Movement in Argentina
- 2001: War in Afghanistan
- 2001: G8 Summit in Genoa
- 2003: Second Gulf War
- 2004: Asian Tsunami
- 2004: Madrid train bombings
- 2005: Banlieue riots in France
- 2005: Hurricane Katrina
- 2005: London bombings
- 2006: Anti-CPE movement in France
- 2006: Comuna de Oaxaca
- 2006: Second Lebanon War
- 2007: Subprime Crisis
- 2008: Onda movement in Italy
- 2008: War in Georgia
- 2008: Riots in Greece
- 2008: Pomigliano Struggle
- 2008: Global Crisis
- 2008: Automotive Crisis
- 2009: Post-election crisis in Iran
- 2009: Israel-Gaza conflict
- 2020s
- 1920s
- 1921-28: New Economic Policy
- 1921: Communist Party of Italy
- 1921: Kronstadt Rebellion
- 1922-45: Fascism
- 1922-52: Stalin is General Secretary of PCUS
- 1925-27: Canton and Shanghai revolt
- 1925: Comitato d'Intesa
- 1926: General strike in Britain
- 1926: Lyons Congress of PCd’I
- 1927: Vienna revolt
- 1928: First five-year plan
- 1928: Left Fraction of the PCd'I
- 1929: Great Depression
- 1950s
- 1970s
- 1969-80: Anni di piombo in Italy
- 1971: End of the Bretton Woods System
- 1971: Microprocessor
- 1973: Pinochet's military junta in Chile
- 1975: Toyotism (just-in-time)
- 1977-81: International Conferences Convoked by PCInt
- 1977: '77 movement
- 1978: Economic Reforms in China
- 1978: Islamic Revolution in Iran
- 1978: South Lebanon conflict
- 2010s
- 2010: Greek debt crisis
- 2011: War in Libya
- 2011: Indignados and Occupy movements
- 2011: Sovereign debt crisis
- 2011: Tsunami and Nuclear Disaster in Japan
- 2011: Uprising in Maghreb
- 2014: Euromaidan
- 2016: Brexit Referendum
- 2017: Catalan Referendum
- 2019: Maquiladoras Struggle
- 2010: Student Protests in UK and Italy
- 2011: War in Syria
- 2013: Black Lives Matter Movement
- 2014: Military Intervention Against ISIS
- 2015: Refugee Crisis
- 2018: Haft Tappeh Struggle
- 2018: Climate Movement
People
- Amadeo Bordiga
- Anton Pannekoek
- Antonio Gramsci
- Arrigo Cervetto
- Bruno Fortichiari
- Bruno Maffi
- Celso Beltrami
- Davide Casartelli
- Errico Malatesta
- Fabio Damen
- Fausto Atti
- Franco Migliaccio
- Franz Mehring
- Friedrich Engels
- Giorgio Paolucci
- Guido Torricelli
- Heinz Langerhans
- Helmut Wagner
- Henryk Grossmann
- Karl Korsch
- Karl Liebknecht
- Karl Marx
- Leon Trotsky
- Lorenzo Procopio
- Mario Acquaviva
- Mauro jr. Stefanini
- Michail Bakunin
- Onorato Damen
- Ottorino Perrone (Vercesi)
- Paul Mattick
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Vladimir Lenin
Politics
- Anarchism
- Anti-Americanism
- Anti-Globalization Movement
- Antifascism and United Front
- Antiracism
- Armed Struggle
- Autonomism and Workerism
- Base Unionism
- Bordigism
- Communist Left Inspired
- Cooperativism and autogestion
- DeLeonism
- Environmentalism
- Fascism
- Feminism
- German-Dutch Communist Left
- Gramscism
- ICC and French Communist Left
- Islamism
- Italian Communist Left
- Leninism
- Liberism
- Luxemburgism
- Maoism
- Marxism
- National Liberation Movements
- Nationalism
- No War But The Class War
- PCInt-ICT
- Pacifism
- Parliamentary Center-Right
- Parliamentary Left and Reformism
- Peasant movement
- Revolutionary Unionism
- Russian Communist Left
- Situationism
- Stalinism
- Statism and Keynesism
- Student Movement
- Titoism
- Trotskyism
- Unionism
Regions
User login
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.