31 March marks the thirtieth anniversary of the Poll Tax riots. The demonstration, called by the Anti-Poll Tax Federation (set up by the Militant Tendency) and supported by local anti-poll tax groups, attracted some 200,000 people and turned violent following heavy handed arrests and charges by mounted riot police. Unrest lasted for hours and resulted in over 300 arrests and over 100 injured. But this was only one spectacular event in a months' long fight which saw off Margaret Thatcher and which ended a year later, on 21 March 1991, with the announcement by John Major (who had replaced Thatcher as PM and leader of the Tory party) that the Poll Tax would be abolished.
By definition this was a tax that affected everyone. Whilst the very rich and those with more than one house were actually better off, the working class majority definitely were not, especially people in council houses and private tenants who had not been rate payers. There was widespread hostility (over 70% of the population opposed it according to opinion polls). In fact, because it attacked the whole class at once (and not each sector as had happened with steel, coal and printworkers, etc.) the Poll Tax inspired a more generalised and active working class fightback than the miners' strike had ever done (for all its militancy, the miners had remained largely self-isolated round their slogan "Coal Not Dole'). In particular, there was a strong campaign of non-payment, and local resistance against bailiffs who tried to seize the possessions of those who had not paid. This was the most substantial evidence that, even after the annihilation of key sectors of the old industrial working class and the demoralisation that followed the defeat of the 84/85 miners’ strike (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2009-09-01/british-capitalism-and-t…), the working class has no alternative but to fight.
Here we collect our coverage of this anti-Poll Tax movement from old issues of Workers’ Voice, as well as two leaflets distributed in Sheffield (which for the next few years would become the home-base for the CWO). Significantly, these articles reveal the hypocrisy of the left of capital: the Labour Party (which opposed the Poll Tax in words, but enforced it in action), the trade unions (which refused to support demonstrations and even their own members who wouldn’t collect the tax), the Militant Tendency (which offered to hand over names and photographs of Poll Tax rioters to the police), and the SWP (which tried to pressure union bosses to their side). Not much has changed since!
The Poll Tax was just the tip of the iceberg of larger events going on around the world – the fall of the Berlin Wall and the gradual collapse of the Eastern Bloc (https://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2019-11-09/the-fall-of-the-berlin-w…), as well as the First Gulf War. It was a difficult period for the Communist Left, as the defeats of the 80s meant relatively few newcomers to our politics. In fact, some groups of what back then we called the “proletarian political camp” did not see the Poll Tax as a class issue at all (since it affected everyone). In some ways, it was a turning point for the CWO, as we resolved not to turn our back on the class (and a personal matter, as some of our members were summoned to court over non-payment). As for the Poll Tax, its legacy still lives on in the reformed Council Tax that replaced it – hundreds of people in England are still being jailed for being unable to pay it, while Council Tax arrears are the most common debt problem people approach Citizens Advice about (https://www.ft.com/content/d1ef81ea-da25-11e9-8f9b-77216ebe1f17).
Make It Easy On Yourself, Don’t Pay The Poll Tax – Fight All Capitalist Attacks!
From Workers' Voice 49, December/January 1990
The latest Government advertising campaign calling on us to “Make it easy on yourself” (with appropriate music) is a sign of desperation. By getting us to sign direct debits to pay the poll tax they hope to minimise the resistance to its introduction in England.
In Scotland there are now so many refusals to pay that 5 of the 9 regions have already asked for warrants to arrest the sums from wages and bank accounts. Lothian Regional Council admits to arrears of £25 million and has asked for 76,000 court orders against individuals. As the power of the state in Eastern Europe declines, what value is Western ‘freedom’ when a law rejected by a majority can be imposed by sequestrating wages?
The Financial Times, that well-known supporter of government policy, warned in 1987 that “Plans for the destruction of local democracy are now complete … Britain will be more than ever a centrally managed state, with power concentrated in Whitehall.” (17.8.87)
The poll tax is also a result of the continuing crisis of the capitalist system. Its aim is to both cut costs of local government and to shift the burden of payment from the propertied middle class to the working class. A millionaire will now pay the same as a council worker. That’s democracy for you.
But this is only one of a series of attacks on the working class. Cuts in benefits to those who are unemployed, the ending of wage councils for the low paid, the threat of redundancy for those who resist deteriorating working conditions, the rise in homelessness, are all part of the same offensive to make the working class pay for the crisis. According to official figures over 16.5 million are living on or near the margins of poverty.
And this is why the poll tax cannot and should not be fought on its own. Throughout history tax strikes have generally failed since the government of the day can pick off the individuals piecemeal (as they will do here). Indeed, the only time a revolt against taxes was successful (and it was the introduction of a poll tax which caused it) was the Peasants’ Revolt of 1381 when the Chancellor of the day was killed!
A really successful fight against the poll tax cannot be confined to petitions and demonstrations. It can only be fought by striking back at the political system which produced it. This means for a start the rejection of the manoeuvres of the Labour Party. Many Labour councillors in Scotland have refused to pay on a personal basis whilst the party they belong to stands for respect for capitalist law. In fact these ‘radical’ Labour councillors cannot be trusted, otherwise they would make sure that the councils they lead would have fought the poll tax by refusing to collect it. Their fake radicalism is just a smokescreen to hide the fact that the Labour Party is so far inside the system that it not only cannot lead the real fight against it but actively seeks to prevent militant resistance.
If we are to wage a fight against the poll tax we must link it to the fight against all capitalist attacks. This means linking up strikes, making strike demands with political conditions such as a withdrawal of the tax and creating a movement of such widespread resistance that the ruling class, both Conservative and Labour, will be forced to rethink. There is a great reservoir of class anger but it will not be tapped until every section of workers in struggle receives the support and solidarity of every other section.. The Tory game is divide and rule, our aim must be to unite and fight.
H.M. Govt — Wanted For Poll Tax Fraud
From Workers' Voice 51, April/May 1990
The Poll Tax is a massive attack on the working class. Its introduction means a shifting of the burden of local taxation from the bosses to the working class. But this shift is only part of the attack. According to The Guardian (12 March 1990), the average household will pay 33% more in this year’s Poll Tax than in last year’s rates. Because the bosses tend to live in the better houses this average figure hides a reduction in the bosses’ share of the burden and an even greater increase in the working class’ share. So the average working class family will face an increase far in excess of 33%.
What the Poll Tax was For
Back in the mists of time, when the bosses still believed in the Thatcher dream, the Tories thought up a scheme which would forever banish the Labour Party to the fringes of capitalism’s political spectrum. Believing that the shift which had temporarily reversed the fortunes of British capital was just the start of something big (given enough gin, anyone will believe what’s in their interest to believe!) rather than the end of something piteously small, they looked forward to a home-and-share-owning aristocracy of labour which would vote Tory out of gratitude. To speed the creation of this aristocracy, a wonderful device was designed: the Poll Tax, sometimes known as the “Community Charge”.
The idea was this: the members of the property-owning democracy, including the hoped for aristocracy of labour, would have a common interest in a low Poll Tax because their children would get into the best schools and they could afford to pay for their own text books once they got there; they would be materially unaffected by council rents or lack of repairs to council houses, their elder relatives could be cared for privately, whereas the reverse would be the case for those excluded from the property-owners through their “fecklessness” in being unemployed or poorly paid. If the Tories could have created this permanent division in the working class they would have achieved one of the bosses’ historic ambitions, and would, no doubt, have used this division to push down the living standards of both segments of the working class. If, in addition, they had been able to identify the Labour Party with the disenfranchised, they would have succeeded in identifying the historic interests of the whole bourgeoisie with their own interest.
However, this depended on the gradual introduction of the Poll Tax. This is why the tax was initially intended to be introduced over ten years.
Capitalism’s Crisis Wakes Up the Tory Dreamers
But reality has a way of intruding on fantasies built on fortuitous accidents: British capitalism may well have benefited, in the short term, from Thatcher’s restructuring of the economy with its greater reliance on financial activity, but it is not immune from world capitalism’s unavoidable crisis. Finance capital appears to be profitable independently of industrial production and this illusion is strengthened when national capitals are considered apart from their global interconnection. Nevertheless, wealth does not spring into existence by a miracle wrought by the mere existence of the banking system and a stock exchange. Behind the apparent independence of financial institutions from production there lie mechanisms for draining value from production, such as interest on loans and the export of capital. Internal to capitalist production there is the tendency for the rate of profit to decline, and this means that the financial institutions’ sources of value also tend to dry up. Manifestations of this are debt rescheduling and actual defaults, which have an obvious effect on the profits of the lending institutions.
The British consequences of all this are clear: Maggie’s miracle no longer works. Not only that, the bosses have known this for a long time, and have been hoping for a subsidiary miracle to bail them out. Of late, they have been aware that this is not and will not be forthcoming: hence the Lawson resignation. As if the high interest rates were not enough, Britain has had its first ever deficit in invisibles (i.e. financial services, etc.). For a bourgeoisie that has staked so much on invisibles this is not just worrying, it amounts to a death knell for the government whose policy this was.
In a crisis the bosses are unanimous on what has to be done: make the workers pay. There are many tried and tested weapons in their armoury that they can use to do this. The Tories, however are going to try out their new weapon.
What the Poll Tax is For
Faced with the intensified crisis, one of the things the bosses need to do is reduce the burden of state spending on business profits. This can be done either by reducing state spending or by making the working class pay more of the burden. Both of these methods are attacks on the working class: the first because what is cut are the services that workers use and the workers in those services are made redundant, and the second because it involves effective wage cuts.
The Tories have decided to use the Poll Tax for this. They have reduced its phasing-in period from ten years to overnight in the hope that they can use it to blame “Labour’s high spending councils” for the general crisis of capitalism. They have even gone so far as to try to recreate last century’s rotten boroughs (Victorian values with a vengeance?!) in Wandsworth (Poll Tax £148) and Westminster (£195). In reality they have cut central government grants (but not in Wandsworth or Westminster!) to make workers pay for the crisis. The general effect of this is made worse by the high interest rates on local government loans — £4.7million to be paid by Ipswich alone (The Guardian, 9 March 1990).
The Labour Party, as a loyal party of capitalism, not surprisingly resents a Tax aimed at marginalising it as being responsible for all the ills of that system. More important, this Tax is both extremely unpopular and unambiguously identified with the Tories. If Labour wants to be taken seriously as an alternative government it simply has to oppose the Poll Tax. However, if we look more closely at the nature of its opposition, we will see that we are justified in calling it a capitalist party.
Firstly, in its public statements it concentrates exclusively on the “unfairness” of the Tax. We do not, of course, disagree that the Tax is particularly unfair (even by the standards of this “unfair”, i.e. exploitative society), but we are for workers fighting any attack on their living standards, no matter what form it takes. In a nutshell, we would oppose a 33% increase in rates too. The Labour Party is more concerned with making sure that capitalism gets it 33%, but “fairly”.
Secondly, how does the Labour Party propose we fight this attack on us? It tells us to wait passively until there is an election, to vote Labour and then wait again until the Labour Party gets round to abolishing the Poll Tax. (Jeff Rooker, Labour’s former local government spokesman, tells that his party will take two years to abolish it! The Guardian, 24 February 1990).
What does the Labour Party plan for “action” amount to? We pay Poll Tax for two years to a Tory government, while they help that government to collect it, and then we pay it to a Labour government for two more years while they work out a “fairer” way to lower our living standards!
Even if we give the Labour Party the benefit of the doubt, and assume that it is genuinely against the form of the Poll Tax, its actions show that it is far more interested in keeping the working class passive than in defeating the Tax. Its interest in the passivity of the working class derives from its nature as a capitalist party. Capitalism cannot coexist with a working class which is conscious of its interests and fights for them. It becomes nervous when a minority of workers begin to develop consciousness and seeks to draw those workers back into a belief that their interests can be entrusted to the system. Bourgeois democracy is the tool par excellence for this job.
Every few years we are given a chance to choose which representative of the bosses we want in Parliament. This is the only time we get to exercise any power over him (and it is usually a man), and the bosses make sure that we only do this as atomised, isolated individuals, unaware of our own power to make collective decisions. When “our” man gets to Parliament, he is under the influence of the bourgeoisie and the bourgeoisie alone. Just to make sure that workers do not have any influence over anything important, Parliament has been reduced to the farce we see on our television screens.
Meanwhile, the bosses use their own economic power over the government to exercise their dictatorship over society. Parliament functions only to disguise this dictatorship.
How We Can Fight the Poll Tax
What we must not do is wait. This would only tell the bosses that they can do whatever they like with us and cause us to fall into demoralisation. Our anger must be used to build on the already strong campaign of non-payment, no matter how often the Labour Party tells us to respect the bosses’ law. This means that we must defend anyone who is faced with the bosses’ attempts to steal their property to pay their bills.
In addition we must defend those workers who refuse to collect the Tax and strike against any bosses who comply with court order authorising wage deductions for non-payment.
This may well not be enough. To hit the government where it hurts, we need to hit the bosses who stand behind it. This means strikes directly against the Poll Tax, rather than just against its effects. No doubt the government will denounce the strikes as being political, and the Labour Party will remind us that such strikes are against the law, but this will only be an attempt to demobilise us. Besides, it is the government which is showing us that politics and our domestic economy are intimately linked!
This does not mean that we support the SWP’s strategy of forcing the union bureaucracy to start strikes:
"They [activists] need to recognise that most workers, still cowed by ten years of defeats under the Tories, aren’t confident enough to act without official backing from union leaders … That means using every opportunity to step up the pressure on labour movement leaders to demand they match their speeches against the poll tax with calls for action." (Socialist Worker, 24 March 1990)
It is true that many workers lack confidence. It is not true that this lack of confidence can be overcome by using the union bureaucracy. Union bureaucrats only ‘lead’ strikes when they respond to already existing mass pressure from below. And then they lead them to defeat, either directly or by throwing away what was won in struggle at the negotiating table. The last ten years is replete with examples of this, and the ambulance workers case is only the most recent. (The bureaucracy, in the shape of Poole, opposed their struggle at first, then “supported’ it – but only in words – and finally sold them out.)
Socialist Worker’s advice would result in the most active workers throwing their efforts into improving the union bureaucracy’s image (by implying that they could be won to the struggle), instead of galvanising other workers. The only way to overcome workers’ lack of confidence is to go to them directly, and this is what we stand for.
How is it supposed to increase workers’ confidence by encouraging them to surrender control of their struggles to the union bureaucracy? It is necessary that workers control their own struggles, through mass meetings which debate the real issues facing them, and which exert direct democratic control over any delegates or strike committees elected by them on the basis of instant recall. These are the elements of proletarian democracy.
And After the Poll Tax…
It is certainly possible for the Poll Tax to be defeated. But capitalism’s driving force is not the maliciousness of the Tories or even of the bourgeois political parties as a whole (although they can certainly be malicious), but the thirst for profit, especially in the face of crisis. If they lose the Poll Tax, they will have no choice but to attempt other attacks on us. We, on the other hand, would have no choice but to fight back using the lesson we learn in this struggle.
Although temporary victories have immense value (they enable us to survive for a start!), if the working class really wants to have a decent life, it must defeat capitalism as a whole, and run society in its own interest, the interest of the vast majority. This means the transformation of society through the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat, which will involve every worker in running the whole of society, and eventually lead to the abolition of classes, to communism.
The Poll Tax Struggle Goes On
From Workers' Voice 52, June/August 1990
The battles with the police during the poll tax demonstration of 31 March and the rioting which followed were an expression of elemental anger at this tax. They expressed the anger of some of those who have suffered the hardest blows from Thatcherism, those working for poverty wages, the unemployed, the young, the homeless. For the last decade Thatcherism has singled out these sections of the working class and attacked them mercilessly because they cannot fight back. By doing this it has attempted to drive wedges through the working class and divide workers to prevent any general fightback to increased exploitation and lower living standards. By marginalising the poorest and weakest sectors of the class it has also driven down the basic level of wages.
The poll tax is simply the latest in a series of attacks including higher rents, lower social security payments, the rundown of the health service, and forcing the young to work for starvation wages. On the 31 March, in response to police provocation, the anger boiled over and the centre of London was turned into a battlefield.
Though rioting cannot on its own achieve a better society, it expresses a will to combat the injustices of this society, which could become a will to fight for a new social order.
Those who are fighting for the interests of the working class, while they may point to the limitations and weaknesses of rioting, cannot condemn it or fail to defend those captured by the police. The London events have revealed the real nature of many of those who claim to defend the interest of the workers – class enemies posing as friends.
Workers' Enemies
The party which has roundly condemned the demonstrations and called for the savagest sentences on those arrested at the London demonstration is, of course, the Labour Party. The reason for this is that the Labour Party is simply the bosses' left wing party, a loyal party of capitalism which fundamentally supports the general aims of the Tories. The most important of these aims is to make British capitalism profitable again, and this means increasing the exploitation of the workers and lowering their living standards. As the latest policy review shows they support and will retain most of the Tory anti-working class laws (e.g. criminalising secondary picketing). The party maintains that the way to defeat the Poll Tax is to vote Labour in 1992. Though many workers believe this is it is completely untrue. The Labour Party wishes to keep alive the lie that workers can advance their interests through parliament. They pretend that workers’ struggles should be directed to parliament because they know that this is the way to defuse and defeat these struggles. The truth is that we live under the dictatorship of the capitalist class. Over a hundred years ago the British ruling class decided that they had nothing to fear from democracy. After all with control of the media they could ensure that only those parties which supported the continued existence of the capitalist system could be elected. Labour was only accepted into the fold once it had supported the war effort in the First World War. Parliament is therefore just a device the ruling capitalist class use to disguise who really rules.
What do they offer us for the Poll Tax? Even if Labour were elected in 1992, they would only abolish the tax after two further years (i.e. 1994) before they brought in their own tax. In other words we have to pay the tax for the next four years! Meanwhile the Labour councils continue to collect the tax and prosecute those who can't or won't pay. The trade unions have not supported the demonstrations. They called for "legal" protest and supported the lies of the Labour Party. The particular unions involved in the collection of the tax, e.g. NALGO, have refused to support their members who won't collect the tax!
The left fringes of the Labour Party, e.g. Militant, have similarly revealed their anti-working class character. The Militant leadership of the "Anti-Poll Tax Federation" announced after the London battles that they would hand over names and photographs of the rioters to the police. To put it plainly they offered to help the bosses mercenaries in their job of oppressing workers and forcing us to submit to the injustices of capitalism. On the edges of the fringe of the "labour movement" there stands the SWP. Arguing that workers are not confident enough to take on the bosses on their own, they say that we must pressurise the union bureaucracy into leading the struggle against the Poll Tax. This argument falls down on at least two counts: firstly, the union bureaucracy has no interest in promoting the kind of autonomous struggle that has a chance of success; rather, if such a struggle existed, they would attempt to lead it back onto the terrain of the bosses' legality and parliamentary niceties. Secondly, how do you put pressure on the bureaucracy if working class struggle does not already exist? The whole argument about pressurising the bureaucracy leads to the channelling of such workers' confidence and combativity that exists into a campaign to bring the struggle under the control of the enemies of class struggle. The SWP's way forward is a dead end. This is the so-called "labour" movement, the so-called "friends of the working class". The Labour Party screws the tax out of us, the unions isolate anyone who won't help the bosses screw us, and when we dare to defend ourselves the so-called "left" wing of the Labour party denounces us to the police! The real aim of the so-called "labour" movement is to undermine real resistance to this tax. Any fightback needs to be outside of and against this labour movement.
The Fightback
For most workers there is no choice of whether to oppose this tax. They cannot pay and are forced to fight. The most effective way to defeat the tax would be through a campaign of strikes against the tax. For those workers in work this is the way forward. The demand should be the abolition of the tax for all workers and the strikes should be organised to do the maximum damage to the bosses' economy. Such a campaign should be organised outside of and against the unions.
At the same time a defensive guerilla campaign should be conducted against the tax. We should not pay the tax and obstruct the authorities at every stage when they try to get it out of us. We should support organised local resistance to the bailiffs when they try to seize the possessions of those who have not paid.
The Future
Although this is a particularly unjust tax it is simply another of the injustices of capitalist society. As long as capitalist society exists the bosses will continue to attack us as this is the only way they can restore falling profit rates and so the only way the system can survive. To end these attacks once and for all the working class needs to destroy capitalism and create a communist world. This has nothing to do with the state capitalist system which is collapsing in Eastern Europe, but is production for human needs planned and organised on a world scale by the working class. Defensive struggles like those against the poll tax need to become part of a more general struggle to destroy capitalism and give the working class the programme for building communism. The first step towards achieving this is the creation of a political party which unites those who are most conscious of the need to end capitalism and build a classless society without exploitation. It is to this end that revolutionaries must intervene in the Poll Tax struggle.
No to War! No to Imperialism! …And NO to the Poll Tax!
From Workers' Voice 53, September/October 1990
Five months after the introduction of the Poll Tax it is estimated that 20% of those registered have not paid. In some areas, mainly in the inner London boroughs, the default rate is as high as 37%, and these figures do not include those who have avoided registration. It is obvious that millions of people are boycotting what is probably the most vicious anti-working class tax in modern times.
As we have stated before in Workers Voice the Poll Tax is more than an alternative bureaucratic measure for raising local government revenue, but is designed to shift the burden of taxation from the Tory voting middle classes (previously high rate payers) on to the working class. In other words, workers are being asked to pay more for declining services.
Having been unable to persuade vast numbers of people to pay up voluntarily, local authorities are now using the courts against non-payers. Throughout the country numerous demonstrations and protests have occurred both inside and outside the courts. Whilst we do not criticise these actions in themselves, it is necessary to point out the limitations of these protests from a communist perspective. It must be remembered that the courts are not a forum where workers can challenge the state on equal terms. The entire legal system is designed to favour the capitalist class and its state. There is no legal defence to non-payment of the Poll Tax so that although courtroom protests can serve a useful propaganda function, they can only delay the legal procedure and do not ultimately prevent the issue of liability orders which enable the state to collect the tax by force.
Only Working Class Solidarity Can Resist the State’s Attacks
Workers cannot succeed on a battleground chosen by the bourgeoisie where all the rules are determined by the state. As with anti-strike legislation, the only effective opposition by workers takes the form of mass actions outside of and against the legal framework. There have been encouraging examples of workers organising to resist the bailiffs who are empowered to seize goods to pay the tax, and this type of resistance should be spread to every working class neighbourhood if serious opposition to the Poll Tax is to be maintained. Also, strike action should be organised against bosses who agree to implement attachment of earnings orders against workers’ wages.
The high point of the anti-Poll Tax campaign was the mass demonstration in London at the end of March, which was the largest political demonstration in Britain in recent years. Unfortunately there was no political leadership to galvanise the anger and resentment against the Poll Tax into a mass campaign of opposition. By insisting on remaining within the law, those false friends of the working class, the Labour Party and the unions, successfully diffused the protest movement leaving workers to fight on as vulnerable and atomised small groups and individuals. Now the anti-Poll Tax movement is fighting a rearguard guerrilla action as the mass protests have, at least for the time being, been subdued.
Whether the present non-payment campaign will be sufficient to cause the Poll Tax to be abandoned remains to be seen. Inevitably next year’s Poll Tax bills will be considerably higher. (Not only will workers be asked to pay for this year’s revenue shortfalls and the interest on local authority borrowing to cover these shortfalls, but will also be asked to pay for the giant bureaucracy needed to administer a tax which is inherently expensive to collect.) This may create a fresh impetus for anti-Poll Tax struggle.
Whatever the outcome, it is important that communists do not fetishise the Poll Tax issue which must be seen as part of the ruling class’ overall strategy to make workers pay for capitalism’s crisis. In the final analysis workers need to struggle against all attacks on their living standards, whether these take the form of the Poll Tax, income tax, wage cuts, speed-ups or unemployment. Such a generalised struggle can only be waged outside of the Labour Party and the unions who represent the left wing of capitalism. Only working class solidarity can resist the state’s attacks.
The Anti-Poll Tax Struggle is Part of the Class Struggle
From Workers' Voice 54, November/December 1990
The Scene
A wet Friday afternoon outside the specially designated ‘Poll Tax’ court in Sheffield. Regular as clockwork the Courts’ entrances are locked so that nobody can get into the public galleries during the poll tax cases. Gradually a quiet, solemn queue of people summoned for non-payment forms alongs
