The Great Myth of Magna Carta

All societies have their creation myths, Adam and Eve, Romulus and Remus and many others. But these myths are not limited to the ancient world, and capitalist society has its share of myth and mystification that are intended to legitimise the class rule of the bourgeoisie. For the Anglo-Saxon world and even beyond, Magna Carta serves this role; 800 years old last month we are told that it is the foundation of freedom, democracy and the rule of law.

Unlike Adam and Eve and other fairy tales of ancient times, there is no doubt about the historical fact of Magna Carta. It was signed at Runnymede in June 1215 by a reluctant King John in the face of an uprising in London led by powerful barons who resented the King's arbitrary imposition of taxes. So how has, what was in effect a peace treaty to prevent a civil war between the monarch and the elite of feudal society, been elevated by people such as the founding fathers of the American constitution down to minor entities such as David Cameron, as the font of bourgeois liberty?

We are told that the Magna Carta is the foundation of the 'rule of law', a concept close to the heart of the bourgeoisie. It's a term that can have several meanings but there are arguably two main ones. The first is that the rule of law is a euphemism for the rule of the law of property rights of the ruling class. Magna Carta purported to do this for the rights of the feudal barons, long before the concept became fetishised by the bourgeoisie. The second meaning concerns the idea that nobody is beyond the law, including governments, and of course in the time of Magna Carta, the monarch. So noble was this concept that within weeks of Magna Carta being signed, it was annulled by the Pope at the behest of the King John. Later, after more civil unrest, and after King John's death, Magna Carta was reissued by his son Henry III in 1216, and following further breaches it was issued again in 1217 and 1225.

Even during the feudal period Magna Carta became an irrelevancy and was largely forgotten. Later on in the sixteenth century, in what was the dawn of the modern era, the Chief Justice of England Edward Coke was dismissed from his post for claiming that the king, James I, was not above the law. Coke then wrote The Institutes of the Lawes of England in which he claimed that Magna Carta was the basis of the English common law. This would appear to be the origin of the myth of the Magna Carta.

In modern times, as in medieval time, the idea of the state being subject to the law is a constitutional myth. The big flaw in this article of bourgeois faith is that the state makes the law. It is true that in liberal democracies the courts do find particular actions of governments to be unlawful from time to time and sometimes governments accept the court ruling. If however the state finds the court ruling to be inconvenient, all they have to do is change the law.

Another myth is that Magna Carta forms the basis of democracy because it created some sort of council of barons to keep a check on the monarch. Even in 1215 this was not a new idea. In the pre-Norman period, the Anglo-Saxon 'Witan', councils of 'wise men', were appointed to advise the monarch. And of course there was nothing remotely democratic about these institutions, even the idea of democracy did not really emerge before the English Civil War in the 17th century and it would be another 200 years before the British Parliament even remotely represented the mass of the population, and universal suffrage was not fully implemented until 1928.

The next myth arising from Magna Carta is the idea that it established equality before the law. It talks about not denying, delaying or selling justice. A fine sentiment indeed, but rights were only ever intended for the landowning classes. The serfs who constituted a significant part of the population had no legal rights at all. In class societies the idea of equality before the law has little meaning. Equally laughable is the claim by some that the right of access to the courts and even to legal aid comes from Magna Carta. Tell that to the women who were put on trial for witchcraft, the peasants who were hanged for poaching or workers who were transported to Australia for petty theft. How grateful they must have been for the rights conferred on them by Magna Carta.

The law is made in the image of the ruling class and in capitalist society this means the bourgeoisie. In liberal democracies, the law creates a semblance of rights for workers, but only insofar as they are not contradictory to bourgeois property rights. Also these so called rights are transient and can be rolled back when they no longer accord with the interests of capital. We have seen this clearly regarding the erosion of employment rights, benefit entitlements and civil liberties in recent years and the trend can only continue as the crisis of capitalism deepens.

So when the Queen, David Cameron and the great and the good of the ruling class rocked up at Runnymede to celebrate Magna Carta's 800th birthday, you could be forgiven for thinking that they were not really celebrating 800 years of freedom, but 800 years of class oppression.

PBD

برچسب‌ها